Elevation: A Neglected Emotion in the Realm of Ethics; A Critical Analysis

Document Type : Original Article

Author

kums

Abstract

The main issue in the following article is that the main driver of the emotion of elevation cannot be only helpful and exceptional social behavior. Of course, the exceptionality of the driver of the emotion of superiority is not very questionable, and my personal experience and yours also shows that predictable and ordinary behaviors or events do not lead to the stimulation of the feeling of emotion. However, more thought should be given to the issue of socially helpful behavior. The effect of this feeling is not the same in all behavioral areas. the feeling of emotion does not have much effect on justice-seeking or protesting behaviors. In addition, not all people are affected by this feeling to the same extent, and depending on the strength or weakness of their identity or moral sensitivity, this feeling has a different effect on individuals. In summary, based on the findings of the article, it can be said that the stimulus for a sense of emotion is not confined to socially helpful behaviors, and amazing beauties, deep austerities and prayers that are far from showing off, forgiveness of major mistakes, and the like can also be a stimulus for a sense of transcendence.  .

Keywords


فهرست منابع
افلاطون .(1401)‌. دوره آثار افلاطون‌. (ج ۱، ترجمه: محمد  حسین لطفی، رضا کاویانی)‌. شرکت سهامی‌انتشارات خوارزمی.
زگزبسکی، لیندا‌. (1401)‌. الگوگرایی در اخلاق‌. (ترجمه: امیرحسین خداپرست)‌. نشر کرگدن.
داستایفسکی، فئودور‌. (1398)‌. برادران کارامازوف‌. (ج ۱، ترجمه: صالح حسینی)‌. نشر ناهید.
صادقی، مسعود‌. (1404)‌. معنا و ابعاد اخلاقیِ سپاسگزار  فصلنامه اخلاق‌پژوهی،  8(2), 5-26‌. doi:10.22034/ethics.2025.52056.1800
 
Algoe, S‌. B., & Haidt, J‌. (2009)‌. Witnessing excellence in action:  The ‘other-praising’emotions of elevation, gratitude, and admiration‌. The journal of positive psychology, 4(2), 105-127.
Ali,‌ S‌. (2021)‌. Exploring the prosocial effects of moral elevation in middle childhood and early adolescence (Doctoral dissertation,‌ University of Kent).
Aquino,‌ K.,‌ McFerran,‌ B.,‌ & Laven,‌ M‌. (2011)‌. Moral identity and the experience of moral elevation in response to acts of uncommon goodness‌. Journal of personality and social psychology,‌ 100(4),‌ 703.
Diessner,‌ R.,‌ Rust,‌ T.,‌ Solom,‌ R‌. C.,‌ Frost,‌ N.,‌ & Parsons,‌ L‌. (2006)‌. Beauty and hope:‌ A moral beauty intervention‌. Journal of Moral Education,‌ 35(3),‌ 301-317.
Freeman,‌ D.,‌ Aquino,‌ K.,‌ & McFerran,‌ B‌. (2009)‌. Overcoming beneficiary race as an impediment to charitable donations:‌ Social dominance orientation,‌ the experience of moral elevation,‌ and donation behavior‌. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,‌ 35(1),‌ 72-84.‏
Gibhardt,‌ S.,‌ Hepach,‌ R.,‌ & Henderson,‌ A‌. M‌. (2024)‌. Observing prosociality and talent:‌ the emotional characteristics and behavioral outcomes of elevation and admiration in 6.5-to 8.5-year-old children‌. Frontiers in Psychology,‌ 15,‌ 1392331.
Haidt,‌ J‌. (2000)‌. The Positive emotion of elevation‌. Prevention & Treatment,‌ Volume 3,‌ Article 3.
Keltner,‌ D.,‌ & Haidt,‌ J‌. (2003)‌. Approaching awe,‌ a moral,‌ spiritual,‌ and aesthetic emotion‌. Cognition and emotion,‌ 17(2),‌ 297-314.
Keyes (Vol‌. Eds.),‌ Flourishing:‌ Positive psychology and the life well-lived:‌ Vol‌. 275,‌ (pp‌. 275-289)‌. Washington,‌ DC:‌ Am‌. Psychol‌. Assoc.
Klebl,‌ C.,‌ Dziobek,‌ I.,‌ & Diessner,‌ R‌. (2020)‌. The role of elevation in moral judgment‌. Journal of Moral Education,‌ 49(2),‌ 158-176.
Kristjánsson,‌ K‌. (2017)‌. Emotions targeting moral exemplarity:‌ Making sense of the logical geography of admiration,‌ emulation and elevation‌. Theory and Research in Education,‌ 15(1),‌ 20-37.
Lai,‌ C‌. K.,‌ Haidt,‌ J.,‌ & Nosek,‌ B‌. A‌. (2014)‌. Moral elevation reduces prejudice against gay men‌. Cognition & emotion,‌ 28(5),‌ 781-794.
McGuire,‌ A‌. p.,‌ Fagan,‌ J‌. G.,‌ Howard,‌ B‌. A‌. N.,‌ Wurm,‌ A‌. I.,‌ & Szabo,‌ Y‌. Z‌. (2022)‌. Changes in trauma-related cognitions and emotions after eliciting moral elevation:‌ examining the effects of viewing others' virtuous behavior on veterans with PTSD‌. Frontiers in health services,‌ 1,‌ 831032.
Schnall, S., & Roper, J‌. (2012)‌. Elevation puts moral values into action‌. Social Psychological and Personality Science, 3(3),‌ 373-378.
Schnall, S., Roper, J., & Fessler, D‌. M‌. (2010)‌. Elevation leads to altruistic behavior‌. Psychological science, 21(3), 315-320.
Silvers,‌ J‌. A., & Haidt, J‌. (2008)‌. Moral elevation can induce nursing‌. Emotion, 8(2), 291.
Sparks,‌ A‌. M.,‌ Fessler,‌ D‌. M.,‌ & Holbrook,‌ C‌. (2019)‌. Elevation,‌ an emotion for prosocial contagion,‌ is experienced more strongly by those with greater expectations of the cooperativeness of others‌. PloS one,‌ 14(12),‌ e0226071.
Thomson,‌ A‌. L.,‌ & Siegel,‌ J‌. T‌. (2017)‌. Elevation:‌ A review of scholarship on a moral and other-praising emotion‌. The Journal of Positive Psychology,‌ 12(6),‌ 628-638.
Van de Vyver,‌ J.,‌ & Abrams,‌ D‌. (2015)‌. Testing the prosocial effectiveness of the prototypical moral emotions:‌ Elevation increases benevolent behaviors and outrage increases justice behaviors‌. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology,‌ 58,‌ 23-33.
Van de Vyver,‌ J.,‌ & Abrams,‌ D‌. (2017)‌. Is moral elevation an approach-oriented emotion? The Journal of Positive Psychology,‌ 12(2),‌ 178-185.
Vianello,‌ M.,‌ Galliani,‌ E‌. M.,‌ & Haidt,‌ J‌. (2010)‌. Elevation at work:‌ The effects of leaders’ moral excellence‌. The Journal of Positive Psychology,‌ 5(5),‌ 390-411.
Waddell,‌ T‌. F‌. (2019)‌. When inspiration comes with baggage:‌ how prior moral transgressions affect feelings of elevation and disgust‌. Communication Research Reports,‌ 36(4),‌ 277-286.
Yao,‌ Z.,‌ & Enright,‌ R‌. (2018)‌. The role of consequences of moral action in maximizing moral elevation‌. Journal of Moral Education,‌ 47(4),‌ 451-465.
Yarritu,‌ Ion‌. (2024)‌. Moral elevation affects the causal attributions about others’ behavior‌. The Journal of Positive Psychology,‌ 19(3),‌ 430-441.‏