نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی
عنوان مقاله English
نویسنده English
Any reductive moral theory—one that analyzes moral concepts and judgments entirely in terms of non-normative, descriptive concepts—faces a fundamental challenge. It must provide an adequate explanation of the phenomenology of moral normative authority. This paper examines this challenge as it applies to the moral theory of Mesbah Yazdi. Ultimately, it defends his position.
We begin by analyzing the various dimensions of the phenomenology of normative authority. Next, we argue that Mesbah Yazdi’s theory of "relative necessity" (darurat bi'l-qiyas) adopts a reductive approach. On this basis, we develop two distinct readings—or reconstructions—of his view: a desire-based reading and a teleological reading. Finally, we evaluate how each reading handles the challenge of explaining normative authority, thereby mounting a defense of his overall theory. We demonstrate that while the desire-based reading successfully explains certain aspects of this phenomenology, it falls short of a comprehensive account. By contrast, the teleological reading succeeds. It adequately explains every component of the phenomenology of moral normative authority.
کلیدواژهها English